Martha’s Vineyard is the perfect summer vacation destination. This quaint island off the coast of Massachusetts has that nostalgic summertime feel that will keep you wanting to return year after year!
The perfect activity after a long day on the beach or boardwalk is, of course, grabbing a good old-fashioned ice cream cone. But wait—where’s the best place to get ice cream on Martha's Vineyard? We thought you’d never ask! Luckily, you’re in the right place. Read on for our picks for the best ice cream on Martha’s Vineyard!
Mad Martha’s
Edgartown, Oak Bluffs, and Vineyard Haven
Mad Martha’s has a sweet origin story; it’s said that many years ago a young girl named Martha actually started this ice cream business by accident! One cold winter night, she accidentally left some of her family’s cream out in the barn, and the supply froze over.
At first she was upset over the frozen product, and then she came up with an idea—why not turn this frozen cream into ice cream?! With some time and lots of experimentation, she emerged in the summer with a frozen ice cream treat. Word spread quickly, and soon people were coming from all over the island to enjoy her creations.
To this day, Mad Martha’s remains a favorite on the island! They have three locations: Edgartown, Oak Bluffs, and Vineyard Haven. Stop in to any of the locations for amazing ice cream, exceptional customer service, and an unforgettably good time.
Ice Cream & Candy Bazaar
Edgartown
Discover your new favorite ice cream flavor here! The Ice Cream & Candy Bazaar in Edgartown has 32 flavors to choose from, so you’re sure to find something delicious.
This neighborhood ice cream shop is in its 50th season of serving up cold treats this summer, so it’s clear they know how to keep customers happy. Visit them today to see what all the buzz is about!
The Scoop Shack
Edgartown
The Scoop Shack is a local favorite! They have many yummy options for an afternoon treat, from saltwater taffies and rainbows of candies to an exciting selection of unique ice cream flavors. Mexican Hot Chocolate, Lemon Lavender, Chai Tea Latte, and Cool Mint Oreo are just a few of the wide selection of flavors this charming shop offers.
Bring your kids along and see what their new favorite ice cream flavor is! We’d venture to guess they’ll find a new obsession here. The service is fast and friendly, and customers can’t stop talking about the richness of the ice cream and variety of flavors!
Ben & Bill’s Chocolate Emporium
Oak Bluffs
When trying to find the best ice cream on the vineyard, you of course have to try Ben & Bill’s Chocolate Emporium! It's a constant favorite amongst locals and tourists alike. They know what they’re doing when it comes to all things dessert!
Ben & Bill’s is famous on the island for its outstanding attention to detail, flavor, and overall customer satisfaction. You have to try something from here on your vacation to Martha’s Vineyard, whether it’s a simple ice cream cone or one of their decadent chocolate assortments.
Vineyard’s Best Ice Cream & Coffee
Oak Bluffs
The name says it all—when trying to find the best ice cream on the vineyard, you of course have to try Vineyard’s Best! This spot is located conveniently close to the ferry, so many visitors like to drop in before heading off on their voyages for the day.
Enjoy a delicious ice cream cone while taking in some of the best views Martha’s Vineyard has to offer (which is saying something). We can’t think of a better way to spend an afternoon than eating an ice cream cone by the water!
While they have amazing ice cream, let’s not forget the second half of their name—the coffee! Locals say this spot has the best bagels and coffee in Oak Bluffs, and locals constantly mention the mouthwatering New York-style bagels on the menu as a top favorite. Try it for yourself and see if they live up to the name—we have a feeling you won’t be disappointed!
Big Dipper Cafe
Oak Bluffs
Big Dipper is a quaint neighborhood brunch/ice cream shop that will satisfy both your sweet tooth and your coffee addiction! Swing by for a caffeinated afternoon pick me up or a delicious cone to add some sweetness to your itinerary.
Folks love the laid-back vibe of the Big Dipper and keep returning not only for the delicious ice cream and coffee but also for the friendly customer service. You can also try a variety of brunch and breakfast foods here, so if you’re hungry it’s a great place to stop!
Located just a block from the beach and conveniently close to the ferry, Big Dipper is the perfect neighborhood café to add to your list. Give them a visit on your way over to the beach!
Book Your Martha’s Vineyard Vacation with Sandcastle Realty!
Well, now we really want to go get an ice cream cone at one of these awesome spots! You can, too, on your next trip to Martha’s Vineyard. All you need to do is book your vacation, and then you’ll be set to go!
Whether you’re looking for a pet-friendly rental, want to make sure that you’re renting a house on the water, or just want to be positive you’ll have a stunning ocean view, Sandcastle Realty has you covered. We have a wide selection of vacation rentals all across Martha’s Vineyard, sure to fit all of your vacation rental needs. Browse our available vacation rentals now and book your Martha’s Vineyard Vacation direct with Sandcastle Realty!